By Clara Team
Clinical records software breach: what to do
If the software where you keep your patients' clinical records has a security breach, your responsibility to your patients and to the Spanish Data Protection Agency (AEPD) does not pass to the provider. If you work on your own account, you are the controller of the data and the provider is the processor. If you work for a centre, the controller is usually the centre: tell it straight away. This guide sets out what to do in the first days, for a practice in Spain. It is for guidance and does not replace legal advice.
Direct answer: ask the provider in writing what happened and which of your patients' data is affected, assess the risk, notify the AEPD within 72 hours of becoming aware unless the breach is unlikely to put people at risk, tell your patients if the risk is high, and document everything, including a decision not to notify.
What a personal data breach is
The GDPR (Article 4.12) defines it as a security incident that leads to personal data being destroyed, lost or altered, or disclosed or accessed without authorisation. It does not take a cyberattack: someone viewing clinical notes without permission, a setting that exposes documents or a lost copy are breaches too.
In a psychology practice, the data involved is usually health data, a special category. A note or a transcript can reveal far more than a diagnosis. That is why a breach at your clinical records software almost always deserves a careful assessment.
Who does what: you and your provider
The provider, as processor, must tell you without undue delay once it becomes aware of the breach (Article 33.2) and help you with the information you need (Article 28.3.f). Check your processing agreement: some providers commit to a specific deadline.
You, as controller, decide whether to notify the AEPD (Article 33) and whether to tell your patients (Article 34). Do not wait for the provider to give you everything: your deadline runs from when you become aware of the breach.
The first steps
1. Ask for the information in writing
Ask the provider, and keep the answers:
- What happened, and since when.
- Which data is affected: identification and contact details, notes, transcripts, documents, audio, invoices.
- Which patients, or how many.
- Whether the data was encrypted, and whether the keys were compromised too.
- Whether the breach is contained and what they have done.
- Whether they know of the data being published or used.
- Whether the clinical records are still available and complete, or whether anything was lost or altered.
2. Assess the risk to your patients
Think about the consequences for people, not the technical incident. What matters most is the type of data: a clinical note weighs more than a phone number, but in a psychology practice even a name on your patient list reveals that someone is in therapy. Then how many people are affected, including partners and relatives who appear in the notes or in couple and family records, whether minors or vulnerable people are involved, whether the data was readable and whether it left the provider's control. The AEPD has a free tool, Asesora Brecha, that helps you decide whether to notify.
3. Notify the AEPD unless a risk is unlikely
Unless the breach is unlikely to put people's rights and freedoms at risk, you must notify the AEPD without undue delay and within 72 hours of becoming aware of it (Article 33.1). With clinical notes involved, that exception is rare. You do it through the AEPD's electronic office. If you work in a public or publicly funded service, the authority may be your region's, such as the APDCAT in Catalonia. If you do not have all the information yet, you can notify what you know and complete it later (Article 33.4). If you miss the deadline, notify anyway and explain the reason for the delay.
4. Tell your patients if the risk is high
If the risk is high, you must also tell the people affected, in plain language (Article 34): what happened, its likely consequences, what has been done and whom they can contact. It is not required, for example, if the data was encrypted so that nobody without authorisation can read it and the keys were not compromised. If telling each person would take disproportionate effort, a public communication can be used instead.
For someone in treatment, the news is also a clinical event. If you can, tell them yourself, in session or by phone, before any written notice, and leave room to talk about it. Start with the people the exposure could put at risk, for example in situations of intimate partner violence. With minors, use clinical judgement on how to tell their guardians and the young person.
5. Protect your access and prepare your patients
Change your password, turn on two-step verification if the software offers it, and check whether you used the same password elsewhere. After a breach, emails or messages that exploit practice data may follow. Tell your patients you will never ask them for data or payments through a channel other than the usual one, and that if anyone contacts them claiming to have their notes, they should not pay and should let you know.
6. Document it, even if you do not notify
Article 33.5 requires you to document every breach: what happened, its effects and the measures taken. If you decide not to notify, write down why. It is the first thing you will be asked for if the AEPD or a patient raises it later.
What to ask before staying with the provider, or choosing another
After a breach, it is worth reassessing the provider with specific questions:
- Whether it encrypts clinical data field by field before storing it, or only encrypts the disk. The difference matters: with the first, a copy of the database cannot be read without the keys.
- Who on its team can see your patients' data, and whether every access is logged.
- How many hours its contract gives it to tell you about a breach.
- Where the data is stored and which other providers are involved.
- Whether you can take a full copy of the clinical records, which you still have to keep, and have the provider delete its own if you leave.
The guide on what to look for in clinical notes software and the GDPR guide for psychologists go into these questions. Security and data protection shows how Clara answers each one.
Frequently asked questions
Who notifies the AEPD, the provider or me?
You, as the controller of the data, or the centre if you work for one. The provider must tell you and give you the information, but notifying the AEPD and deciding whether to tell patients are up to you.
When do the 72 hours start?
When you become aware of the breach, usually when the provider tells you or when you find it yourself. If the provider does not give you everything in time, notify what you know and complete it later. If more than 72 hours have passed, notify anyway and explain the delay.
Do I have to tell all my patients?
Only if the risk is high, and only the people affected. If the breach exposed readable clinical notes, it most likely is.
What if the provider gives me no information?
Ask in writing and keep your requests. Notify with what you know and, if things get complicated, consult a lawyer or your professional association.